Thursday, January 12, 2012

Part 1 - Process Theology - In The Beginning

Proponents of the new atheism  often use first man in space, Yuri Gagarin's words, to drive home a point: "I looked and I looked, but I didn't see God." The common Christian response is, "Well, of course not! God is Spirit. You can't see God."

Now, that's fine and acceptable, but what we forget as Christians is that Yuri Gagarin may have been a hardcore materialist believing only in what he could see and touch, but his words were also motivated by a
particular Christian view of God being "up there" or "out there" somewhere; you just have to watch our sports people who seem to always look up and give thanks as if God is in some distant realm up in the heavens somewhere.

Process theology does not think in this way. The Divine is always seen to be a reality within. God expresses God-self  from within and through creation. A beautiful illustration of this, and I always come back to it, is a seed. The seed, moved by something within, unfolds in to what it is meant to be. Outwardly you can do to it whatever you like,  but if it doesn't have within it that inner design or energy to unfold in a process of becoming, it will simply remain a dead, hard little husk.

To begin to understand process thought and the concept of God being within, there's no better place to start than with Scripture and the beginning - the Genesis creation stories.

The traditional way of understanding God's creative work in these stories is by saying that there was a time when God was alone, and then, suddenly, God decided to create the earth and everything else, almost as if God got a little lonely and wanted companionship, a kind of Gepetto and Pinocchio thing. The big word theologians use for this is, Creatio ex Nihilo. It simply means God created all creation out of nothing. In other words, before creation there was only God, nothing else. This for centuries has been the orthodox way of believing and it has had a profound effect on the way our faith has been shaped. In some of the next studies we'll see how. Many of us  to this day continue to believe in this way.

There is however a different interpretation of the creation stories and it's the one process theology holds. It's this.

According to these creation stories God does not create the world out of nothing. At no time in these stories is God pictured as being "alone" with nothing else present. On the contrary we're told, "In the beginning when God created the universe, the earth was formless and desolate. The raging ocean that covered everything was engulfed in total darkness and the Spirit of God was moving over the water."

Right in the beginning the Divine Spirit and the stuff of creation are together, relationally and intimately connected, even though the stuff of creation is desolate and formless. We cannot separate God's presence from creation, nor can we separate creation from God's presence.

And so  God speaks from within the stuff of creation and the reality of creation begins to unfold and take shape, something which is still happening as it all grows in to greater levels of love, truth and consciousness. So God's continuous act of creation is in and through creation and not on creation from the outside.

The concept of creatio ex nihilo - God creating out of nothing and being separate from creation, has led to devastating consequences for our  world. A classic example today is the profound concern being expressed for the environment. The moment we come under the illusion that we, like God (being made in God's image) are also separate from the created world, we begin to somehow believe that we can do anything we like to the natural world without it ever affecting us, almost as if we are immune by virtue of our being separate from it. On the otherhand, the realization that we are created in the image of God who is intimately connected and embedded in creation, helps us to experience our dependence on and the sacredness of creation.

As we will see later, the concept of creatio ex nihilo not only affects our relationship to the natural world, but also many other aspects of our faith. The great shift that we have to make in postmodern Christianity is the one from separation to deep connection,  from without to within. Process theology helps us to do that. Once we have made this shift it becomes the foundation on which we can build anew. There's much that we have to unlearn. It's scary, but wonderfully exciting and full of adventure.

Between this post and the next, let's just think deeply around this issue and comment as  we feel. See if you can make any other connections, besides the one I've described with the natural world, in the way you practice your faith.

14 comments:

  1. The distinction between Pantheism - God is all things and Panentheism - God is in all things and all things are in God must be kept. I do feel this distinction in what you have said. Maybe it just needs to be emphasized, Ps 139 a good example of Panentheism. Outstanding post. You have a way of conveying concepts simply.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Allan. Thank you for the emphasis you make - it's absolutely crucial. Ps 139 is certainly a marvellous example of the God who is in all things and in whom all things exist. I also love the way Paul describes us as living and moving and having our being in God.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Epiphany blessings to you, Don.

    Thanks for the post. It is thought provoking and timely for me. I look forward to reading more. I have been reading and thinking a bit lately about creation. I agree that creatio ex nihilo means creation of out of nothing but I wonder if it is sometimes misleading. Nothing becomes something in our thinking. I think of ex nihilo as no-thing. Nothing is not the same as absence. In the beginning there was only God. God, being infinite, contains within God's self all possibilities including self-negation. So maybe "nothing" is God's self-withdrawal (but not his absence) that makes space or room for creation. On a personal level, every time we experience the seeming absence of God it is a withdrawal, not an absence, that makes space - nothing - for the creative act. Creation then is ongoing. That is how God sustains the world and life.

    I am not sure how this fits - or whether it even does - with process theology; so help me out and correct where necessary. Thanks so much.

    Peace, Mike+

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow Mike I really need to ponder on this. Deeply insightful.

      Delete
  4. What a thought - God is IN everyone. That means that God in you, is different to God in me. In you, God must be male, and in me God must be female. God IN and not apart from, means that I have to rethink this God. Maybe that is the God I have searched for, the un-partisan God, who is not for this or against that, but God Present, here, yesterday, today.
    Mike, thanks for the challenge you present to me, I do not really grasp or understand, but I am going to sit and think. These little grey cells are being challenged - at last! Pauline.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Thank you Don for this thought provoking new angle on faith. Process Theology is a big word but I believe the idea is surfacing in many guises. The movie Avatar has all living creatures and plants plugged into the Life Force of their distant planet, to the benefit of all. Eastern religions picture our lives as temporary separations from a Collective Life Force, which we re-join on death. Zen parallels our lives with the fleeting droplets of water as a river tumbles over a waterfall, famously stating that the river knows the droplets but the droplets do not know the river. And our own modern day science is showing that all life on earth is a variation of the same life force, controlled by DNA. This code of life, an enormously complex chemical, is made of almost exactly the same stuff in every living thing. I think that far more people than we think have thought their way through the fog of conservative religions and discovered a far more believable and grander God than the one of the scriptures. And that opens the way to new ways of seeing everything.

    ReplyDelete
  6. ..I agree with Rolf..this sounds somewhat similar to the eastern view of God..which by the way i have no problem with..i know a cistercian monk who seems to teach this perspective in the few talks of his that i've attended...Process Theology would also help to verify the interesting new theories of everything being touted by the cutting edge of Quantum Physics...im curious if any of the better known Christian mystics throughout history ever held to such a theology.....this is getting exciting Don.....

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks Don, I was reminded of the profound statement by the scientist (played by Jodie Foster) in the movie - Contact (1997) - when she exclaims: "They should have sent a poet!" when she is in the machine that took her into the other realm of the universe!
    What I am very pleased about in this post is that you stress our inter-connectedness with Creation and not the 'Process Theology' idea (that has been part of my understanding) that God is not personal.
    Rolf's comment about the movie - Avatar - rings true for me too!
    I look forward to these studies.
    Blessings!

    ReplyDelete
  8. This is brilliant - I really enjoy challenging ideas! In Shantaram, the main character, Lin, and his friend Khader have this amazing discussion in which Khader describes the universe beginning in simplicity and gradually increasing in complexity....moving towards what he calls "Ultimate Complexity" - God. Something of Mike's comment about in the beginning God containing all the possibilities, really makes sense to me - a bit like the seed that hasn't started to germinate yet.
    Rolf mentioned Avatar....which is funny because that is what I was thinking of as an example of a world connected to its life-force. I think perhaps Earth is not so different from Pandora - after studying natural systems I came to the realisation that our environments are not as isolated or unconnected as we would like to think. Perhaps the Na'vi are just more aware of their connectedness? In terms of my own faith I struggle to find connectedness in worship and find I still worship "at" God....
    This is very interesting and intriguing, thanks Don for the thought-spark!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Christine, I find your comment, "In terms of my own faith I struggle to find connectedness in worship and find I still worship "at" God...." rather thought provoking. I wonder to what extent our worship and liturgies have reflected a form of worship that has encouraged a perception of the God "out there" or "up there" and not the God within and in our midst?

      Delete
  9. Hi Don. Thanks for this series.I don't really know what to comment, perhaps some thoughts. I have read a number of books on the theories of how the universe started, and for me the "Big Bang" theory seems realistic. I believe it in no way excludes God, rather I think it simply shows the hugeness of God.
    I Have recently read J.S.Spong's Jesus for the non religious. and he talks of how impossible it is us humans to really know anything about God. I tend to accept this, and all our "knowledge" about God is really only what we believe.
    For what it's worth I believe in a Panentheistic understanding of God.
    Many thanks. Trevor.

    ReplyDelete
  10. ..your so right Don,so much so that often when we want or need to draw close to God we immediately think of going to a church as a rendezvous point and even then we come away wanting..sadly,we've been programed to think this way through the dysfunction of organized religion...for me Meditation has proven a most effective and invaluable tool for improving my conscious contact with God...Christine,you might checkout John Mains book on Christian meditation,it was very helpful to me...

    ReplyDelete
  11. At last I found your 'Part 1" and am looking forward to reading Part 2 and 3. I've always felt many Christians speak of a God who is separate from us, like a big brother looking down - judging - and possibly this is why I've never connected with any church as such. I'm so excited by all you've said Don, and your followers comments. Taking notes and following up with all the different references is hugely exciting for me. I've always felt connected to God through nature - I wonder if its possible to feel that same connection with humanity? Not just in new born babies or philanthropic people, I'm talking even in the ugliness of humanity.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Terry its great to have you with us. I'm so glad that you find you can connect with some of the stuff and your excitement is contagious. I know what you mean by your love of nature - I can so identify with that. The challenge is as you say, humanity itself, especially when it comes to its darker side. Hope you find something of meaning in what you read here. Thanks for taking the time to comment.

    ReplyDelete